top of page

The Hidden Costs of Poor Roofing Work: How Cutting Corners Leads to Expensive Repairs

  • jakemclellan3
  • Sep 29, 2025
  • 3 min read

Your roof is your home’s first line of defense against the elements. Whether for protection, efficiency, or troubleshooting, a professional roof Installation is critical to preventing costly damage. However, when contractors cut corners or make roof installation mistakes, homeowners often end up paying for expensive roofing repair costs later. Let’s explore how poor workmanship impacts your home and your budget.


Costs of Poor Roofing

Common Signs of Poor Roofing Installation


No Leak Barrier Up Walls: A good leak barrier should rise up the side walls several inches or more. In the absence of this, water is able to leak in during periods of heavy rain or ice accumulation, resulting in damage to the structure and mold growth.


Shingles Not Aligned Correctly: If shingles are misaligned or overlap (tucked), this creates weak points in the system where water can get under the shingles and reduces wind resistance. These are clear signs of bad roofing.


Poor Ventilation: Attics aren’t designed to be sealed off, and bad airflow can allow heat and moisture to build up, which can create mold; in the winter it can also help form ice dams, and cause materials to break down faster.


Flashing Problems: Seal flashing joints and seams (including around chimneys, skylights, and vents. Poor placement, installation, or a lack of leak barriers and metal flashing can lead to leaks and significant water damage from roof leaks.


Sagging or Uneven Roof Decking: If the roof seems uneven, it could be a sign of improperly installed decking, excess moisture in the attic, or structural roof issues that will become worse with time.


How Small Mistakes Can Turn into Big Problems


Here are the two most common roof installation mistakes that can lead to failure:


1. Wrong Placement of Nails: The nails must be positioned at specific intervals to hold the shingles correctly. When shingles are afflicted by nails that are driven too high, too low, or at the wrong angle, the shingles can become loose or missing in storms. Lots of missing nails can create weak spots that water can get through.


2. Improper Sealing: Improperly installed or missing leak barrier membranes. The roofing materials have to be installed properly otherwise they lead to leaks Without proper leak barriers and roof deck protection being used in the right places, or simply by using low-grade sealants, water can penetrate the underlayment and do damage that may not be seen for years.


These mistakes can cause significant problems, such as interior water damage, rotting roof decks, mold, and even structural issues. Fixing such issues often requires replacing big portions of the roof which is typically expensive.


Financial Benefits of Investing in Top-Quality Roofing System


Longevity: A properly installed roof system using high-quality roofing materials can last for decades to come with proper maintenance, minimizing the frequency of costly replacements.

Reduced Repair Expenses: Proper installation will reduce the frequency of failures, repairs and high-cost repairs.

Increased Energy Efficiency: A well-sealed and ventilated can help to maintain indoor temperatures, lowering energy bills and maximizing the life expectancy of your new roof system.

Improved Resale Value: A high-quality roof system will provide a great deal of curb appeal and instantly increase property value if you're looking to sell your home. Ask your contractor about transferring your roof warranty to the next owner.


John McLellan Contracting Inc. is one of the best roofing contractors. You can count on us for roof installation, repairs, replacement, and preventative maintenance. Our roofers pay attention to detail to complete the job accurately. Book an appointment with us today by calling 905-767-1240. Let us help you protect your home.

Comments


About John McLellan

John McLellan is the owner of McLellan Contracting and a GAF Master Elite® certified contractor—a distinction held by only the top 2% of roofing contractors in North America. This elite status enables him to offer industry-leading 50-year material and labor warranties, plus 25 years of workmanship coverage that standard contractors cannot provide. With over two decades of experience, John has built his business on quality workmanship, manufacturer-backed warranties, and transparent pricing. He ensures his entire team completes a minimum of five days of certified training annually through GAF and other industry programs—a significant commitment in an industry where 94% of roofers have never had formal training.

 

To maintain Master Elite certification, John's company must requalify annually, meeting rigorous standards for training credits, installation volume, and customer satisfaction. His detailed, itemized quotes help homeowners understand exactly what components protect their investment and why proper installation matters. A vocal advocate for consumer protection, John educates homeowners about the critical differences between minimum code compliance and best practices. McLellan Contracting serves the Durham Region and surrounding communities, bringing professional installation standards and manufacturer-backed peace of mind to every project..

bottom of page